Doubled monthly leads while cutting cost per lead 29%
Family law Google Ads rebuild: 2× monthly leads, −29% cost per lead.
Client: Brown Carrington PLLC · Practice: Family law, divorce · Markets: Kentucky, Indiana, Ohio, Colorado, Georgia, Florida · Engagement: Jan 1 – Sep 30, 2026 · Channel: Google Ads Search · Media managed: $275.6K
How a Google Ads rebuild for Brown Carrington PLLC turned a scattered eight-market account into a lead engine, by separating budget clients from complex cases, writing ads to how people actually search for divorce, and tying ads to the CRM.
Strategy and account management by Jon Larson, PPC lead, with Sauer Agency.
Results at a glance
- Leads per month: 358 → 719 (2.0× volume)
- Cost per lead: $59.69 → $42.58 (−29%)
- Conversion rate: 14.5% → 20.0% (+5.4 pts)
- Phone calls per month: 192 → 344 (+79%)
Nine months under our management (Jan–Sep 2026) compared with the five months of prior management on record (Aug–Dec 2025), normalized per month. Leads are Google Ads conversions: form submissions and qualified calls. Monthly spend rose 43%; leads rose 101%.
The situation: good firm, noisy account
Brown Carrington is a family law firm with offices across Kentucky, Indiana, Ohio, Colorado, Georgia and Florida. It sells two very different products: an affordable, flat-fee uncontested divorce handled mostly online, and full-service representation for contested and high-asset cases. The firm wanted more qualified leads for the bigger matters without paying premium prices for budget shoppers.
When we took over in January, the account was spending about $20K a month across seven locations and returning leads at roughly $60 each. The audit found the usual problems at scale:
- Up to eight ad groups per city campaign, with the bottom groups getting no impressions
- Exact- and phrase-match copies of the same keywords split into separate ad groups
- Uncontested-divorce ad groups inside every city campaign, competing with a statewide uncontested campaign
- A branded ad group sitting inside non-branded campaigns, and thin negative keyword lists
- Broad DMA targeting, and no link between ad clicks and what happened in the CRM
The trend: volume doubled in month one and held
The restructure landed in January: leads jumped from 553 to 894 and cost per lead fell to $32. Q1 averaged $35 per lead, inside the $25–35 target band set at kickoff. The June dip reflects a call-tracking migration, when phone calls briefly stopped recording as conversions (35 tracked calls versus 300+ in a normal month), not a drop in demand. Spend also rose through the year as new markets launched.
The strategy: five moves that did the work
1. Split the budget client from the complex case
We pulled uncontested divorce out of the city campaigns and gave it dedicated statewide campaigns for Kentucky and Indiana (Ohio later), each with its own flat-fee landing page. City campaigns were left to compete for contested, full-service work.
Proof: Jan–mid-Mar, uncontested campaigns produced 716 conversions vs 187 in the prior period.
2. Write to the experience, not the job title
Search terms showed people look for the experience of divorce, not for a lawyer. We rebuilt uncontested campaigns around five intent groups: Uncontested, Affordable, DIY / No Court, Fast & Easy, and Online.
Proof: "Affordable" ads earned a 22% CTR vs 9% for "divorce attorney."
3. Collapse the structure
We consolidated duplicate exact and phrase ad groups into a few intent-focused groups per campaign, paused low-intent groups such as child custody, moved brand terms out of non-brand campaigns, and standardized negative keywords.
Proof: Cost per lead fell 33% in the first 10 weeks.
4. Spend where clients actually convert
A zip-code analysis showed $10,517 of the first $70K had gone to zip codes that never produced a lead. We tightened geo targeting to proven zip codes and fixed a Louisville/Indiana overlap that kept ads out of New Albany.
Proof: Louisville cost per lead fell 34% in 2026.
5. Connect ads to the CRM
We captured click IDs through the web forms into Zoho, moved call tracking to a single platform, validated every call number, and began sending "consult set" outcomes back to Google Ads, so bidding could learn from booked consultations instead of raw form fills.
Proof: 1,095 CRM-qualified leads and 143 paid consultations from Google Ads through July.
Uncontested divorce became the efficiency engine
The two statewide uncontested campaigns produced 43% of all 2026 leads on 25% of spend, at $24–26 per lead. "Divorce papers" became the top-converting ad group in Indianapolis, and Google's category data showed online-divorce searches growing 16% year over year.
- Spend: $70.1K of $275.6K (25%)
- Leads: 2,787 of 6,473 (43%)
Click-through rate by search theme (Q2 + July 2026): Affordable 22% · Fast 10% · Easy 10% · Family law 9% · Divorce attorney 9%
Prospects search for the experience of divorce. "Affordable," "fast," "easy" and "divorce papers" outperformed traditional legal terms.
By market: competitiveness sets the price of a lead
Cost per lead by campaign, Jan–Sep 2026 (leads · cost per lead · change vs prior):
- Uncontested – IN: 1,101 leads · $24.00 · new
- Uncontested – KY: 1,686 leads · $25.90 · leads +799%, CPL −3%
- Louisville: 874 leads · $30.60 · leads +154%, CPL −34%
- Indianapolis: 812 leads · $35.24 · leads +126%, CPL −11%
- Lexington: 721 leads · $36.95 · leads +120%, CPL −25%
- Cincinnati: 598 leads · $43.49 · leads +88%, CPL −14%
- Atlanta: 265 leads · $90.63 · leads +249%, CPL −49%
- Palm Beach: 166 leads · $161.20 · leads +137%, CPL +14%
- Denver: 166 leads · $170.99 · leads +57%, CPL +14%
- Covington (July launch): 40 leads · $192.83 · new
In the established Kentucky, Indiana and Ohio campaigns, leads ran $24–43 and every core metro improved on the prior period: Louisville conversions rose 154%, Indianapolis 126%, and Lexington's conversion rate climbed 55%. In Denver, Atlanta and Palm Beach, competition from national directories and large firms pushed costs past $90 per lead even after Atlanta's cost per lead fell 49%.
We treated those metros differently: we fixed ad rank and landing pages before adding budget, launched Complex Divorce campaigns with six niche ad groups (high-asset, business owner, physician, crypto, privacy, prenup), started a target-CPA test, and began setting up Local Services Ads. Lead volume in a saturated market is bought with Quality Score first and budget second.
Beyond the click: from lead to paid consultation
- CRM-qualified leads: 1,095
- Consultations booked: 396
- Paid consultations: 143
Platform conversions show volume; the CRM shows business. By connecting the two we could report what executives care about: 396 booked consultations and 143 paid consultations from Google Ads in seven months (Jan–Jul 2026), with offline conversions flowing back into Google Ads so bidding could start optimizing for consultations. CRM-qualified leads are deduplicated and screened, so they run lower than ad-platform conversions.
The engagement, in order
- Dec 2025 — Audit and six-month plan: account audit, baseline cost per lead, and a test roadmap (keyword isolation, new campaign types, bid strategy tests).
- Jan 2026 — Restructure: paused city-level uncontested ad groups, consolidated duplicate ad groups, added converting search terms, tightened negatives, started weekly status reports.
- Feb–Mar — Uncontested split and geo analysis: separate Kentucky and Indiana uncontested campaigns with intent ad groups; zip-code performance mapping across all eight markets.
- Apr–Jun — Measurement build: CRM integration plan, click-ID capture, call-tracking consolidation, and call-number validation with the Google rep.
- Jul — Expansion: Covington launch, Complex Divorce campaigns in Denver and Atlanta, brand name pinned to headline 1, target-CPA test in Denver.
- Aug–Sep — Optimizing to consultations: offline "consult set" conversions importing to Google Ads, exact-match tightening in Atlanta and Indianapolis, landing page consolidation.
What this means for your practice
- Separate your products in the account. If you offer a flat-fee or uncontested option, give it its own campaigns, pages and budget. Mixed together, cheap clicks crowd out the cases you want most.
- Match the language people type. "Affordable," "fast" and "divorce papers" outperformed "divorce attorney." Ad copy that names the outcome earns more clicks at lower cost.
- Simplify before you scale. Fewer, intent-focused ad groups gave Google's bidding more data per group. The biggest efficiency gain came in the first month, before any budget increase.
- Target clients, not regions. One in seven dollars was going to zip codes that never converted. Zip-level targeting is free money for multi-office firms.
- Measure consultations, not clicks. Connecting Google Ads to your CRM shows which campaigns produce paying clients and lets the bidding learn from them.
About the numbers
All ad metrics come from the firm's Google Ads account. "Prior management" covers Aug 1 – Dec 31, 2025, the earliest data in the account; "our management" covers Jan 1 – Sep 30, 2026. Per-month figures are period totals divided by months. Campaign comparisons are against the prior period. CRM figures come from the firm's marketing dashboard through July 2026. Prepared October 2026 by Jon Larson.